I always thought for New Yorker captions, you read it, there's a microsecond of blankness, and then it hits you and you find it funny. 'Just water for me' was funny - it was a quick laugh - but I personally didn't think it was a New Yorker-type caption.
#NEW YORKER CARTOON CAPTION CONTEST HOW TO#
The caption, 'Teach you how to fish,' was bad and not funny at all.
Really? In what universe is "Just water for me, thanks" funnier than Brody's "They lied - I'm from Brooklyn?" More than two months later, Brody is still upset, telling KQED: "I don't think I should have come in third. The three caption finalists are put to a popular vote of readers (about 1,500 people vote in each contest, Mankoff says) and Brody's caption came in a distant third, behind the second-place caption, "Or I could teach you how to fish," and the winner, "Just water for me, thanks." So big that Davis' biggest newspaper, The Davis Enterprise, ran a news item with a headline that announced to the entire community, "Davis resident a finalist in New Yorker cartoon contest." Brody was thrilled. Paul Noth / The New Yorker Collection / The judges of The New Yorker's caption contest, led by cartoon editor Robert Mankoff, chose Brody's caption as a finalist, which was a big, big deal. What on earth would a freshly served fish say to a diner? Here was the caption by Howard Brody, a Davis research scientist: "They lied - I'm from Brooklyn."
In the Jissue, for example, here was the cartoon: A man sits at a restaurant table staring wide-eyed at his dinner plate, where a fish is staring back and talking. And so does the frustration for thousands of contestants - many in the Bay Area - who think they deserved better treatment from The New Yorker's popular contest. Only three are named finalists.īut the submissions keep coming. About 5,000 people submit entries for each contest. The New Yorker is America's preeminent weekly magazine for the arts, foreign affairs, and other integral subjects, and the contest draws smart people around the world who think their words deserve to be in the magazine's hallowed pages.
#NEW YORKER CARTOON CAPTION CONTEST SERIES#
The “Bridgerton” prequel series “Queen Charlotte,” on Netflix.Every issue, The New Yorker has a contest asking readers to submit a caption for a cartoon that's already been drawn.Do our media-friendly defamation rules hurt our democracy?.How a disaster expert prepares for the worst.infiltrates wildlife-trafficking rings to bring them down. What a subway killing reveals about mental illness and homelessness.Ī Reporter at Large: Hunting the Hunters.Our Local Correspondents: The Revolving Door Wind on Capitol Hill: Too Late for the Trees Tables for Two: West African in Brooklyn Garden Layers, Park Crochet, Picasso Problems.Louis Langrée, the Shed’s Sonic Sphere, Tanglewood.David Byrne, “Hamlet” in the Park, “The Doctor”.The New Yorker is at once a classic and at the leading edge. The New Yorker takes readers beyond the weekly print magazine with the web, mobile, tablet, social media, and signature events. Founded in 1925, The New Yorker publishes the best writers of its time and has received more National Magazine Awards than any other magazine, for its groundbreaking reporting, authoritative analysis, and creative inspiration.
0 kommentar(er)
